Showing posts with label direct response. Show all posts
Showing posts with label direct response. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Listen Up. I’m only going to tell you once…

The masters of marketing say that you have tell prospects what you are going to tell them... then you tell them... and then you remind them of what you told them. In other words, repeat your message.

Repeat Your Message!

So why would you think that one email or one direct mail or one tweet or one text message would be enough? Surely one of anything will pull in some business, but if there were an easy way to multiply your effectiveness wouldn't you want to do it?

You'd be an idiot not to! And yo' Momma didn't raise no idiots. Right?

But if you've read this far you already know how to create this marketing magic.

Need a hint?

Go back and read the first paragraph again. And again.

Got it now? Repeating your message is good marketing.

No, I'm not saying to robotically say the same thing over and over again until you hypnotize your audience into zombie-like group think. I'm saying to use multi-channel marketing. Mix the media, but not the message.

Mix Marketing Media.Need corroboration? Consider this statistical gem: Direct, targeted direct mail, combined with a same-day delivery of an email can boost response rates above 10%.

It starts with direct mail. 98% of consumers retrieve their mail the day it is delivered; and 77% of that 98% sort through it immediately. A great DM piece—well written, well designed, well presented—grabs eyeballs and attention. It probably lands in a "to do" pile, and it probably brings in a 3-8% return.

Now add a little "sweetener" in the form of a complementary email. Same message. Same graphics. Same call to action. Same day. Voila' marketing magic!

OK, usually only 10% of your email recipients open your email, and only about 10% of that 10% click through to your offer. Now that's an itsy bitsy group, but if the email and the DM appear on the same day, they exponentially reinforce each other.

Let me say it one more time:

Mix your media and repeat your message.

Then get out of the way.

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

What Goes Around Comes Around, "Snail mail" gains new creds

Snail MailJust a few years ago, when online marketing was still a twinkle in the eyes of the marketing technocrats, those same overly ambitious techies prematurely announced, “Direct Mail is Dead.” 

And while the premature announcement of DM’s demise didn’t make the cover of Time Magazine, it nonetheless shook the marketing community to its roots. 

Direct mail (DM), the long-time savior of all things marketing, became denigrated as “Snail Mail” — slower than the electron-fast e-mail marketing that was rising to prominence.  Fast was in; slow was out.  Shotguns were in; rifles were out. 

Well, that view is so... yesterday.

Today, the brilliant target-ability of direct mail has proven its worth as a tried-and-true in-the-trenches marketing success story.  Sure, DM has taken a hit from email and its electronic cousins.  Mail volume has dropped dramatically over the last 10 years, hurting both the USPS and providers of mailing services.

But consider this:  your letter/postcard/catalog/package now shares the mailbox with far fewer competing pieces of mail.  That means your recipient has longer to ponder your offer than ever before.  You get more “eyeball time,” and because there is less competition, response rates are rising again.

More Eyeball Time

One retailer analyzed side-by-side marketing performance of three media:  DM, email and in-store promos.  With response up 150% from the previous year with no significant change in strategy, DM was the hands down winner over flashier new media.

So here’s the headline:  Snail mail, the so-called “obsolete marketing media,” is outperforming digital, including social media.  Who’d a-thunk it just 10 years ago?  DM is leading the new marketing wave.

The Past is Prologue.

Word.

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Direct Response Vehicle

Direct Marketing Tip of the Day.

Direct Response Rule #1: Always provide a response vehicle.
But it isn’t always as straightforward as it seems.

Q: I saw a membership appeal from another organization recently. They used a #9 BRE. We always use a return envelope, but ask our donors to supply postage. Are we missing the boat? Does a BRE improve response rates significantly?

A: My answer is definitively “Maybe.”

First the obvious: Many neophyte marketers miss the boat by NOT including a response envelope, even if seeking a donation or hard copy response. Not including a reply envelope doesn’t save money; it costs money. Fewer people respond without that RE. That’s a fact.

Now the more subtle: Does the type of RE (return envelope) impact returns? Consider the options as there are financial and philosophical considerations for each.

BRE vs CRE vs SRE. Let the discussion begin.

BREs (business reply envelopes) are pre-addressed to your organization and you pick up the postage. The donor/member doesn't have to pay for postage, and they like not having to pay. A BRE will probably pick up a few fence-sitters who might not respond if it cost them 44 cents.

Upsides:
a) you encourage more responses and
b) you only pay postage on the responses.
c) good approach for subscription renewals, donations, surveys, etc.
d) encourages prompt response

Downsides:
a) there is an annual fee at the USPS for having a BRM account;

b) there is the hassle of keeping money in the kitty to pay for the response mail

c) BRM postage is more expensive than first class because it is first class + a USPS handling fee. So even though you're paying for fewer pieces coming back, you're paying more per piece. You may be able to ameliorate the extra cost by asking the donor to put his 44-cent stamp on the piece to defray the cost, but you'll still pay the handling fee.

d) There are wackos out there who may want to harm you, and misusing a BRE is an easy way to do it. (see downside [b] above). Extreme case in point: in the 1960 Presidential election, some diehard anti-Catholics taped Kennedy for President BREs to bricks and mailed them back to the campaign. It almost bankrupted the campaign before the USPS recognized and stopped the abuse.

CREs (courtesy reply envelopes) meet the minimum requirement for DM Rule #1: supplying a return vehicle. CREs are pre-addressed to your organization. Typically they have a box where the postage would go, warning “Place postage here” or some similar reminder to the responder to fork over his 44 cents.

Upsides:
a) you're providing a pre-addressed envelope to respond to your offer;
b) the donor/member must pay the postage, so you're off the hook on that expense.

Downsides:
a) you'll get fewer responses because people won't/can't find the postage.
b) you’ll eliminate some marginally committed people.
c) may delay responses as people look for a stamp. Misplace the piece,
then finally mail it.

SREs. (Stamped Reply Envelopes) Here you ante up a 44-cent stamp on each reply envelope before it hits the mail.

Upsides:
a) a donor has no excuse for not responding, as you have made it easy for him to do so.
b) you increase your response rate.
c) You may want to reserve use of SREs for long-time or high-dollar donor/ constituents or for special emergency appeals as it is expensive.

Downsides:
a) expense. 44 cents x the number of pieces you are mailing can be very costly.

Those are the facts. So what's right for YOU?

The question that got this conversation going may be better phrased as “What size a boat are we missing? How many donors/subscribers/constituents have left port without us?”

If you don’t know the answer, then you’re not alone. One option may cost more in absolute dollars out-of-pocket, but what if it generates a great response rate and more dollars? One option may cost less, but it may depress response rates and dollars. Which is best for your organization?

You gotta know! But help is at hand. Direct Mail is an amazingly testable tool, and can generate statistical analysis you can take to the bank. Use those analytics to see what works best for you. And by “best” I mean optimizing returns and minimizing expense.

Here's how: Assume you mail 30,000 identical letter packages, but you’re dividing the mail into three “splits.” In all respects the letters are identical except for the return envelope. The copy is the same. The envelope is the same. Even the class of mail and how the postage is affixed is the same. But one group has a BRE, one has a CRE and one has an SRE.

Most critically, divide your data into 3 equal “splits.” Be sure the data demographics are the same for all the splits. You can inadvertently stack the deck if you load all your big donors into one of the test modules. Doing so will skew your results, won't give you a fair analysis, and will have voided this effort as a fair test.

Mail 10,000 with a BRE; mail 10,000 with a CRE; mail 10,000 with an SRE. Be sure to code each split on the reply card so you can track response rates. After all, the reply card gets separated from its envelope early in the response counting process.

Track responses for percent returned and dollars generated vs cost to generate that response. If one test split produces significantly better (or worse!) results, then you have your answer.

Ta dah! Irrefutable scientific logic wins the day.

The next time you launch a direct response effort, you won’t have to worry about missing the boat. You’ll already have your boarding pass.